GiftBench: which AI is best at holiday shopping?
Status
The test runs in early December 2026. Results, every assistant's full answers and a leaderboard will be published on this page when the run is complete.
What we're testing
We ask five popular AI assistants the same 50 real gift requests and check every answer: does the product exist, is it in stock, is it within budget, does it fit the person, and are the picks varied?
The assistants
- ChatGPT (OpenAI)
- Claude (Anthropic)
- Gemini (Google)
- Perplexity
- Copilot (Microsoft)
How each answer is scored
- It exists. The named product can be found at a real retailer under that name.
- It's in stock. At least one major US retailer lists it as available to buy at test time.
- It's within budget. The typical price at test time is at or under the stated budget.
- It fits the person. The pick suits the age, interests and constraints in the request.
- The picks are varied. The list isn't five versions of the same thing.
Each request is sent once, with exactly this wording and no follow-up, to each assistant's official API with web search turned on where the API offers it. Assistants without a public API are asked in a fresh, signed-out chat where possible. We record the model name, date and time of each answer and publish the full text. Scoring of existence, stock and price is checked against live retailer pages, with a link as evidence for each pick.
The 50 gift requests
Real-world gift questions across ages, interests and budgets. Each assistant gets exactly this wording, in a fresh chat, with no follow-up.
- Gift for my dad who loves grilling, under $75
- Gift for my mom who says she doesn't want anything, under $50
- Secret Santa gift for a coworker I barely know, under $25
- Gift for a 14-year-old boy who likes climbing, under $40
- Gift for a 15-year-old girl who's into art, under $50
- Gift for a 6-year-old who loves dinosaurs, under $30
- Gift for a 9-year-old who's obsessed with Minecraft, under $40
- Gift for my grandmother in her 80s who lives alone, under $50
- Gift for my grandpa who likes woodworking, under $60
- Hostess gift for a holiday dinner party, under $30
- Gift for a coffee snob, under $50
- Gift for a tea lover, under $40
- Gift for someone who just started running, under $75
- Gift for a marathon runner, under $100
- Gift for a home cook who has every gadget, under $60
- Gift for a new baker, under $50
- Gift for a gardener, under $50
- Gift for a houseplant lover in a small apartment, under $40
- Gift for a book lover who reads on a Kindle, under $40
- Gift for someone who loves fantasy novels, under $30
- Gift for new parents with a newborn, under $75
- Gift for a first-time dog owner, under $40
- Gift for a cat lover, under $30
- Gift for a PC gamer, under $50
- Gift for a Nintendo Switch player, under $50
- Gift for someone who works from home, under $75
- Gift for a college student in a dorm, under $40
- Gift for a nurse working night shifts, under $50
- Gift for a teacher from a student, under $20
- Gift for someone who loves camping, under $75
- Gift for a hiker, under $50
- Gift for a frequent traveler, under $50
- Gift for a fisherman, under $60
- Gift for a golfer, under $50
- Gift for a cyclist, under $75
- Gift for someone who loves board games, under $40
- Gift for a puzzle lover, under $30
- Gift for a music lover who still buys vinyl, under $50
- Gift for an amateur photographer, under $75
- Gift for someone who loves cocktails, under $50
- Gift for a wine lover, under $40
- Gift for someone who's always cold, under $50
- Gift for someone who's hard to shop for, under $100
- Gift for my boyfriend of three months, under $50
- Gift for my wife who loves self-care, under $75
- Gift for a teenager who only wants money, under $50
- Gift for a toddler who's 2, under $30
- Gift for a retiree who wants a new hobby, under $75
- Stocking stuffers for an adult, under $15 each
- Last-minute gift I can get on December 23, under $50
Want to be told when results are out, or have a request you think we should add? Get in touch.